TalkHorror - Horror Talk For All Horror Fans

The Tall Man - Phantasm
or
Pinhead - Hellraiser

--

Who's it gonna be!

Now THIS is a crossover they should actually make! It would make a good conclusion to the Phantasm series and a good bridge to "Bloodline".

Pinhead and The Tall Man are pretty much polar opposites (an alien conquistador vs. a demon pain-pimp), one has technology that can rip apart dimensions, one has weapons that can tear apart souls, one says souls don't exist, one is believed to be "beyond technology". Both have a fighting chance; Imagine if a cenobite can be converted to a "tall-being" the way old-man Morningside was, or if legions of gold-spheres can be transformed into armies of cenobite-spheres. If both sides can be warped that way the fight would be epic.

I think the deciding factor would really be the extradimensional aspect: Being of a spiritual nature I believe hell applies to pretty much any world (Unless different dimensions have different versions ), if the tall-beings/minions could be sucked in, Pinhead would most likely take the win. If you take the atheist view of most of the Phantasm series, The Tall Man might be able to tear hell from the inside-out and then continue to conquer Earth.

You have a FANTASTIC view on this
Good points!

yeah man more power to ya, HELLRAISER!!

I like them both, but I gotta choose the Tall Man!

wat did the tall man do to kill people?

He used these weird 'Sphere' things - Called "Sentinels".
They have spikes things that drill into your head and through your brain.
He was a Supernatural Undertaker, who turned the dead into Zombies.
He can levitate objects, and invade his victims minds aswell.

yeah that sounds like some crazy shit, maybe i should have voted for him!! pinhead looks cooler though

Well Pinhead is a Demon, and The Tall Man is some Alien Thing.

Wow, GREAT POLL and very good comparison! I luv em both, but I met Pin-head in person, so I give it to my favorite cenobite!!!!:pinheady:

Mr. Briggs Inc. Wrote:Now THIS is a crossover they should actually make! It would make a good conclusion to the Phantasm series and a good bridge to "Bloodline".

Pinhead and The Tall Man are pretty much polar opposites (an alien conquistador vs. a demon pain-pimp), one has technology that can rip apart dimensions, one has weapons that can tear apart souls, one says souls don't exist, one is believed to be "beyond technology". Both have a fighting chance; Imagine if a cenobite can be converted to a "tall-being" the way old-man Morningside was, or if legions of gold-spheres can be transformed into armies of cenobite-spheres. If both sides can be warped that way the fight would be epic.

I think the deciding factor would really be the extradimensional aspect: Being of a spiritual nature I believe hell applies to pretty much any world (Unless different dimensions have different versions ), if the tall-beings/minions could be sucked in, Pinhead would most likely take the win. If you take the atheist view of most of the Phantasm series, The Tall Man might be able to tear hell from the inside-out and then continue to conquer Earth.

Dude, Awesome post and awesome idea!

Pinhead is a pussy Tall man would kill his ass for sure I met Tall man and he's a pretty cool guy

Mr. Briggs Inc. Wrote:Now THIS is a crossover they should actually make! It would make a good conclusion to the Phantasm series and a good bridge to "Bloodline".

Pinhead and The Tall Man are pretty much polar opposites (an alien conquistador vs. a demon pain-pimp), one has technology that can rip apart dimensions, one has weapons that can tear apart souls, one says souls don't exist, one is believed to be "beyond technology". Both have a fighting chance; Imagine if a cenobite can be converted to a "tall-being" the way old-man Morningside was, or if legions of gold-spheres can be transformed into armies of cenobite-spheres. If both sides can be warped that way the fight would be epic.

I think the deciding factor would really be the extradimensional aspect: Being of a spiritual nature I believe hell applies to pretty much any world (Unless different dimensions have different versions ), if the tall-beings/minions could be sucked in, Pinhead would most likely take the win. If you take the atheist view of most of the Phantasm series, The Tall Man might be able to tear hell from the inside-out and then continue to conquer Earth.

That's a great post. Very well thought-out.

Tall man FTW

You played a good game boy, but now, the Cenobites will devour you! aww:

FBrown89 Wrote:You played a good game boy, but now, the Cenobites will devour you! aww:

No WAY! Tall man FTW!

Mr. Briggs Inc. Wrote:Now THIS is a crossover they should actually make! It would make a good conclusion to the Phantasm series and a good bridge to "Bloodline".

Pinhead and The Tall Man are pretty much polar opposites (an alien conquistador vs. a demon pain-pimp), one has technology that can rip apart dimensions, one has weapons that can tear apart souls, one says souls don't exist, one is believed to be "beyond technology". Both have a fighting chance; Imagine if a cenobite can be converted to a "tall-being" the way old-man Morningside was, or if legions of gold-spheres can be transformed into armies of cenobite-spheres. If both sides can be warped that way the fight would be epic.

I think the deciding factor would really be the extradimensional aspect: Being of a spiritual nature I believe hell applies to pretty much any world (Unless different dimensions have different versions ), if the tall-beings/minions could be sucked in, Pinhead would most likely take the win. If you take the atheist view of most of the Phantasm series, The Tall Man might be able to tear hell from the inside-out and then continue to conquer Earth.

you make some great points

mrblue Wrote:you make some great points

Briggz usually does have some good posts.

Friday The 13th Wrote:Briggz usually does have some good posts.

No, Brigs always has good posts.

I voted for Pinhead not because I wanted to but because logically Pinhead would own The Tall Man even though I would be rooting for him all the way.