Dr. "Frankenstein" Logan (Day of the Dead) vs. Dr. Menard (Zombie)

[Dr. Briggs]

Two scientists, both hated by close colleagues but respected by fellow doctors, both stuck in the middle of a zombie infested setting and both resorting to questionable methods to prove their theories right (and both arguably really awful people). Basically; which one is more "in the right" to you? The insane "Frankenstein" and last hope to cure humanity of the zombie plague, or the stubborn Menard who despite putting himself in harms way to treat the island-only zombie plague, constantly berates his wife and patients for their rational fear?

[CarolinePar]

wow..tough one Briggs -

on one hand I don't respect the bashing of a rational fear esp. one's own wife (even with that whole "for better or worse" thing lurking in the back of my mind)

I need to rewatch the movies again with those who can enjoy discussing them to pieces...

within reason of course

[FreddysFingers]

I'd have to say that both are righteous and in the scheme of horror movies, they're nuts but they accomplished the impossible. However, I went with Logan because he successfully started a new trend of humanizing and almost domesticating zombies. Bub was a landmark in zombie culture. Although Logan may be insane, his insanity has a method.

[CarolinePar]

good one FF