Judges or Voting?

[Creamy Goodness]

This is to coincide with the writing competitions thread. Would members who plan on participating prefer if a panel of judges picked a winner or even a top three of our entries or would you rather have the entries posted in a thread to have the rest of the board vote and pick the winner(s)?

[Chainsaw Brutality]

Only because I volunteered, I picked "panel of judges".


I'm good with whatever is selected though.

[Mfish618]

I have a question of my own......

[Sobriquet]

Voted.

[Creamy Goodness]

I have a question of my own......

And since when do you bite your tongue?

[Mfish618]

And since when do you bite your tongue?

It could happen.....:kick:

[Dr. Briggs]

What's the news on this? I think it could be great :/ . I vote for a panel of judges, so we don't have to worry about few people voting (as there'd be a select group "voting" anyhow), the timeframe they'd vote IN, and there could be the added bonus of constructive criticism.

[Creamy Goodness]

I still needed at least three more participants and another judge. I didn't want to do it if we didn't have enough people. 9-10 seems like the best amount of participants to shoot for.